Plain-English HOA help for Boards, homeowners and agents · Florida and beyond

Your HOA Help Desk, Rosemary T McAvoy

Now in three editions · from $79

The HOA Management Company Selection Kit

Your management contract is one of the biggest lines in your budget. Most Boards have never put it out to bid.

An independent framework for comparing management proposals, built by a Past Board President who has run the process.

So Boards call three companies and ask what they offer. Which means the vendors wrote the requirements, and nothing that comes back can be compared. I built this because I was running the search myself and it did not exist.

It now comes in three editions. A 60-unit association running a straightforward search should not have to buy the same thing as a 600-unit community with a contested one, so every edition includes the complete RFP template, and what changes is how much guidance comes with it.

Compare the three editions →

Essentials $79 · Professional $149 · Premium $179

Delivery, files and license

Instant download after checkout. Every edition is one guide in PDF plus working files you can edit: the RFP template in Word, the scorecard (and in Professional and Premium, the Evaluation Workbook) in Excel. Licensed to one association, to use at every renewal.

The three editions

Essentials

Cover of The HOA Management Company Selection Kit, Essentials edition

$79

For a smaller Board running a straightforward search.

  • The complete RFP Template: nothing cut
  • Management Search Quick Start: the sequence, the five steps Boards skip, the five errors that make a proposal look cheap, and how to decide
  • One-Page Evaluation Scorecard, weighted

Professional

Cover of The HOA Management Company Selection Kit, Professional edition

Most Boards start here

$149

The complete system, for a search you want to be able to defend two years from now.

  • The complete RFP Template
  • The Management Search Roadmap: sixteen phases, who does what, how you know a step is finished, a compressed eight-week version, and a 47-item task checklist
  • The five-tab Evaluation Workbook: three-year cost normalization, 25 red flags, weighted scoring, and the Board packet decision page
  • The Board Facilitator Guide
  • One-Page Evaluation Scorecard, weighted

Premium

Cover of The HOA Management Company Selection Kit, Premium edition

$179

For a contested search, or a Board that wants to run it together.

  • Everything in Professional
  • The Interview Question Bank: more than forty finalist questions across six sections, with follow-up probes and what a weak answer sounds like
  • A weighted interview score sheet
  • Scripts for telling the incumbent and answering owners, plus ready motion language
  • The recommendation memo skeleton

What is in each edition

Every edition is one guide (PDF) plus working files you can edit. A check mark means it is included; a dash means it is not.
What you get $79 $149 $179
The guide (PDF): Start Here, real-world scenarios, Florida Notes, letters and forms✓✓✓
Quick Start process (in the guide)✓——
Part 1: Prep Work and the Board Facilitator Guide—✓✓
Part 2: The Roadmap (16 phases, 47-item checklist)—✓✓
Part 3: Interview Question Bank & Board Scripts——✓
Management Services RFP Template (Word)✓✓✓
One-Page Evaluation Scorecard (Excel, plus a print-ready PDF)✓✓✓
Evaluation Workbook (Excel, five tabs)—✓✓

What it changes

  • A management fee is not a price. Where you have on-site staff, payroll passed through routinely dwarfs the service fee, so a Board comparing headline fees is comparing the smallest part of the bill.
  • Every respondent answers the same questions in the same order, so proposals become comparable instead of merely persuasive.
  • Costs are normalized to a three-year total before anyone scores anything, and the weights are set before the proposals arrive.

And it keeps your Committee straight

  • Formed by Resolution, with a charge and an end date. The calendar runs backward from the one deadline that cannot move.
  • Everyone scores independently before anyone speaks, so the loudest voice does not set the room.
  • The Committee recommends; the Board decides by motion at a noticed meeting, and the minutes carry the reasoning, so the decision still holds up two years later.

A note on the RFP itself

The RFP template carries no logo, no byline and no mention of this system, in every edition. That is deliberate. It is a document your association issues under its own name to firms bidding for your business, and somebody else's branding does not belong on your Board's correspondence. Everything else in the system is yours to keep. The RFP is yours to send.

Yours to keep and use at every renewal. Educational material, not legal advice. Your state statute and your governing documents control the process. Have your association's counsel review the final agreement before anyone signs it. © 2026 Rosemary T McAvoy. All rights reserved.

Want to see pages first? Look inside the Kit on the Bookshelf. Questions about which edition fits your Board? Ask me.

↑